Malcolm Gladwell on “The American Way of Killing”
David Remnick: I'm kind of shocked to say it, but Malcolm Gladwell has been a staff writer at The New Yorker for 30 years. We got here at just about the same time. In his reporting for us, and in a shelf of best-selling books, Gladwell takes ideas from the social sciences and other fields and applies them to topics that most of us had never really thought about. You could almost call Malcolm Gladwell a genre unto himself, but we don't often think of Malcolm Gladwell tackling the news, writing about what's in the headlines every day.
That's exactly what he does in his new book. I'll tell you, it's not easy to read. The book is called The American Way of Killing, and Malcolm's subject is gun violence. He looks at the mass shootings, suicides, and vast numbers of deaths and injuries in this country. I could rattle off the statistics, but by now, you know them only too well. One unbelievable data point. Firearms have been the leading cause of death among American children since 2020. We don't lead the world in gun deaths, but among the wealthy nations, we're an outlier and to a stunning degree. Malcolm Gladwell tries to understand why that is in his newest book. We spoke this week.
Malcolm Gladwell: It's good to see you again, David.
David Remnick: It's been way too long. Your new book is about guns, gun control, or the lack of it, and so on. What are the origins of your interests? I always have suspected that some of it is the fact that you're Canadian and come from a place that doesn't have this madness.
Malcolm Gladwell: I think the longer I stay in America, the more baffled I am in some ways by it. A lot of this book is concerned with the question that the conversation about guns in this country is dishonest. I use that word. I picked that word with great deliberation.
David Remnick: What do you mean?
Malcolm Gladwell: What I mean is that it's not that it's wrong. It's that people aren't arguing about the things they should be arguing about. I'll give you one that I spend a lot of time on in the book, and that is this country is obsessed with homicide rates. I have an old chapter pointing out that that's the wrong thing to be obsessed with. It didn't tell you anything. Why? Because a homicide is a function of two things.
It's how lethal your wounds were, and also how quickly you got to the hospital. If you were to shoot me here in the heart, I'd be at that hospital three blocks away in five minutes. I'm going to make it. If you do the exact same thing to me in the Hudson Valley where I live, I'm dead, right? The level of violence is the same in those first two instances. In one case, I'm a homicide. In one case, I'm not.
That has to do with my access to health care and a skilled doctor and such. One of the things that has happened in America in the last 40 years is the level and quality of medical attention that's being given to gunshot victims has gotten so much better that we have become blind to the extent of our violence. If we held the level of health care constant from 1960 on, we'd have 75,000 homicides a year in this country. We have 20,000 now, whatever it is.
David Remnick: It's still an enormous amount.
Malcolm Gladwell: Still an enormous amount, but what you need to talk about is how many times do people shoot each other? That's what you should be talking about. Don't talk about homicide.
David Remnick: Let's start with the beginning. The Second Amendment is one single sentence. A well-regulated militia, comma, being necessary to the security of a free state, comma, the right of the people to keep and bear arms, comma, shall not be infringed, period. Why is it written like that, what was its original meaning, and why are we so fatalistically attached to it?
Malcolm Gladwell: That sentence is written in a time closer to Shakespeare's time than our own. We don't write sentences like that anymore.
David Remnick: At what point historically does the intent change?
Malcolm Gladwell: The key guy here is this guy named Carl Bogus, this fantastic legal historian.
David Remnick: A Gladwellian name if I've ever heard one. Carl Bogus, a real person?
Malcolm Gladwell: If my name was Carl Bogus, I would be so happy.
David Remnick: [laughs]
Malcolm Gladwell: The brilliantly named Carl Bogus. He does what apparently no one has ever before him, no serious historian had ever done. When the Constitution is drafted, it has to be ratified by the states. The key state is Virginia, right? Virginia is one of the largest states in the Union. All guys are from Virginia. Virginia needs to sign on. They had someone transcribe the entire debate they have in Richmond about whether they're going to ratify the Constitution.
What do you discover when you read these debates? That they are obsessed with the Second Amendment, and they're obsessed with that militia clause. Why? Because militias are the means by which they keep their slaves in check. Most of these people live in communities where the slaves outnumber white people 10:1. In some cases, 20:1. From time to time, there are these slave uprisings. They're terrifying to the planters.
They institute this system of militias, which go around the South and patrol the South. Everyone volunteers for the militia. The Constitution comes along, and these northern states are threatening to take away to nationalize the militia. They're like, "No, this is terrifying. How are we going to stay safe otherwise?" They're desperate for the Second Amendment to reflect the fact that they continue to have a right to have armed militias to keep their slaves in check. That's what it is.
David Remnick: It's not a kind of uniquely American culture that has to do with the frontier and the wilderness.
Malcolm Gladwell: No, and it's not the Revolutionary War. The militias fought so badly in the Revolutionary War that Washington all but gave up on them. The idea that this is an integral part of America's fight for freedom is nonsense.
David Remnick: Let's talk a little bit about the scale here. I think many Americans would agree, we have a mass shooting problem, although we clearly don't all agree on the cause or the solution. Between 1966 and 2023, there have been 184 mass shootings in this country. 184. A total of 1,342 deaths. You point out in that same period, the number of gun-related deaths in general is two million. That's with all the improved medical care that you've talked about. What's driving the number?
Malcolm Gladwell: I have a whole chapter in the book about the difference between instrumental and expressive violence, which is an incredibly important distinction. There are two categories in which a homicide falls. One is instrumental violence. That is to say, I shoot you and kill you in the cause of some other goal. You're wearing a Rolex. I want your Rolex. You struggle. Okay, I shoot you. I take your Rolex, right? I'm robbing a bank. I killed it. I'm defending my turf in the drug trade against some rival gang. That's instrumental violence. Expressive violence, on the other hand, is the violence that comes out of raw emotion. It comes out of a sense of injury, of personal antagonism-
David Remnick: -or mental illness.
Malcolm Gladwell: Mental illness. It's not planned in the same way. It's impulsive. If I thought twice about it, I wouldn't do it, right?
David Remnick: Or had the capacity to- [crosstalk]
Malcolm Gladwell: Where the injury of the other is the point. The assumption always is, when we discuss gun violence, that much of it is instrumental. Almost none of it's instrumental. I put it in a book that if you watch Law & Order, it's all instrumental murders. I was murdering someone because I want their apartment. I want their whatever. No, that never ever happens. No one gets murdered over an apartment.
Violence overwhelmingly, going back hundreds of years, thousands of years, people murder each other for expressive reasons. We get into an argument. I pull a knife and stab you. That's the story of murder in the medieval-- or hit you over the head with something. In America, it so happens that the availability of guns has meant that arguments are more likely to be lethal. We have a whole series of conditions in which arguments are allowed to flourish and persist.
David Remnick: How did this issue get so politically polarized? Supporting gun control was more bipartisan in this country in the long ago late '60s. There was real support for it. It seems people reflexively support the gun policy now of their side. Republican, Democrat, left, right. Why did that happen?
Malcolm Gladwell: I have real issues with some of the strategic choices made by the gun control community. I have a chapter talking about assault rifle bans, which I think are just a stupid waste of time.
David Remnick: When we got rid of AR-15s temporarily.
Malcolm Gladwell: The only reason people are in favor of those bans is they never read the fine print of the bans, which don't ban anything. It's an absurd piece. It's an absurd sideshow.
David Remnick: Before you piss people off accidentally, make sure you're pissing them off on purpose. Yes, exactly. Explain what you mean.
Malcolm Gladwell: Assault rifle bans don't ban assault rifles.
David Remnick: Well, weren't AR-15s banned for--
Malcolm Gladwell: What you have in an assault rifle is a category of relatively light weapon, and it's easily accessorized. When we ban assault rifles, what we do is we ban a series of cosmetic add-ons that we don't like.
David Remnick: Such as?
Malcolm Gladwell: There's a certain kind of handle that people in Congress are upset about, or there's a little thing that would hold a hand grenade. You can't have that. Not to mention, of course, you can't get hand grenades. It's just all the stuff that makes it look dangerous and military. We say you can't have that. You can have the assault rifle, but you can't have any of the gizmos that make it look scary. That's what an assault rifle ban is. It's a complete waste of time. By the way, in mass shootings, assault rifles are often used in mass shootings, but the most lethal weapon in mass shootings is a handgun.
David Remnick: Really?
Malcolm Gladwell: Yes, absolutely. We have very, very good data on this. Even if you were concerned about mass shootings, which I think are another side road we get derailed on, it doesn't make any sense. It's like the problem is guns. If I wanted to murder you, David, I couldn't bring an assault rifle into this office building. They would see it. It's large. I would bring a handgun and conceal it on my person. I would pull it out right now and shoot you. In this instance, a handgun is infinitely more lethal than an assault rifle by virtue of its portability. Why we have this kind of notion that just because a weapon is large and scary-looking, it is more dangerous to us than one that's small and concealable is crazy.
David Remnick: I'm speaking with Malcolm Gladwell, and his newest book is The American Way of Killing. We'll continue our conversation in just a moment. This is The New Yorker Radio Hour.
[music]
David Remnick: I'm David Remnick, and I've been speaking with Malcolm Gladwell, one of the best-selling nonfiction writers of our time. In his new book, Gladwell looks at the problem of gun violence. It's called The American Way of Killing. Here you are, you're sitting with a New York--
Malcolm Gladwell: Upper West Side.
David Remnick: Upper West Side.
Malcolm Gladwell: Every tiresome--
David Remnick: Every tiresome cliché. I'm sitting across the table from the Canadian equivalent who lives in a swell town in the Hudson Valley. Our political views on this align, and they're probably pretty expected. What I hear from people elsewhere in the country is, "You don't understand. This is part of our culture, this hunting. There's a family element to it." I'm not mocking. I'm just trying to be descriptive here. How do you approach that part of the problem, the American-ness, the frontier-ness, the sport aspect of it?
Malcolm Gladwell: Reporting this book, I talk to God knows how many people who are engaged in a meaningful way with gun violence prevention. It is astonishing to me how little they talked about gun control. I'm just doing two episodes of my podcast on what's going on in Baltimore, which has experienced, over the last three years, one of the most profound drops in homicide in history.
David Remnick: Why?
Malcolm Gladwell: Baltimore is doing a strategy where they sit down, and they say, "Okay, you can identify, looking at police records and doing network maps." The portion of the community at any given time that's at risk for being shot or shooting, it's relatively small. It's 1% population. Then you follow those kids, and when one of them has an argument and shoots somebody else, you go see the family and friends of the kid who got shot. You say, "Dude, don't retaliate. We got this. We're watching you. Don't do anything."
That's what it is. It's just these endless cycles of retaliation and revenge. They have these meetings every week where they go through names of people. "Billy's friend just got shot. Can someone go see Billy? Does anyone know Billy's dad?" or, "Joey just shot somebody. They're going to come after his family. Can we move the family to a hotel for two weeks till things calm down so they don't get caught in a crossfire?"
David Remnick: Effective policing, intelligent policing.
Malcolm Gladwell: Not just with police, with community leaders. "Send the pastor to his house. Pastor knows that family for years. The kid's desperate. Tell him we'll get him new housing and some grief counseling because he's lost so many friends over the last-- maybe that helps him." Quite recently, Baltimore had more homicides than New York City. It is one-tenth the size, right? They're going to get under 100 this year.
David Remnick: That's without gun control in the way that you and I mean it.
Malcolm Gladwell: Not even talking about guns. Not even talking about guns. Would they love for there to be fewer guns? 100%. They would give their eye teeth for fewer guns, but it's not going to happen. Not if you're Maryland. Are you kidding me? Someone's just driving guns up from North Carolina every day. It's like, why are we engaged in this fantasy that we can wave a magic wand and remove all the guns tomorrow and everything will be fine? In the meantime, people are dying. What they're doing is saying, "I'm not waiting for this political miracle to happen. I'm going to solve the problem at its root here, which is--"
David Remnick: Why can't the political miracle happen? The statistics show, polls show that, in fact, for all the talk of guns being part of the American fabric and all the culture and all the rest among so many people, people want it. They see the effect of guns in our society. You think it's worthless at this point to approach things in a national legislative sense?
Malcolm Gladwell: Not worthless. You should simultaneously--
David Remnick: Futile.
Malcolm Gladwell: Not futile. I wouldn't even go that far. I'm saying we should simultaneously try to do that. If that effort takes 40 years, then it's not helping us now, is it?
David Remnick: No. In the meantime, tens of thousands of people are dying.
Malcolm Gladwell: It might take 40 years. If you want to wage battle on matters related to the Constitution and those kinds of deeply rooted, we're talking about 50-year increments between defeats and victories, right? I'm fine. Go ahead. Wage your 50-year battle, but I can't wait. The idea that that's what any campaign against gun violence ought to be in its entirety is nonsense.
David Remnick: Now, there's a fascinating thing in this book. You compare the police departments of Los Angeles and Berlin.
Malcolm Gladwell: Yes.
David Remnick: Similar-ish populations. LA has 8,500 police officers, and Berlin has 18,000. What do all those extra police officers do in Berlin?
Malcolm Gladwell: Well, a Berliner would reverse that question and say, "How on earth do you cope in Los Angeles?"
David Remnick: By the way, the debate, of course, on the left here was, for quite a while, that there should be fewer.
Malcolm Gladwell: An idea so completely at odds with any kind of empirical understanding of what police do. I can't even utter the phrase "defund the police" without nearly blowing a gasket. Western Europe and the United States, as a share of GDP, spend roughly the same amount of money on public safety. In Europe, they spend most of that money on police and a little bit on prisons. We spend most of it on prisons and a little bit on police. There is no universe in which our use of resources makes more sense than theirs.
Why would you rather the crime happen because you didn't have enough cops to catch it and then put the person away at great cost for 40 years than to do the reverse? Also, there's a really brilliant paper by two socialists, by the way, at Harvard. Christopher Lewis and Adaner Usmani. They wrote this really fascinating paper where they argue very persuasively that the level of police violence, of brutality by police in America, is a function of the fact that we have too few police and not too many.
Our assumption is when we see police beating up people or whatever, the things that American police do, do in greater numbers than their European counterparts, shoot people with all those kinds of things, we're like, "Oh, that's cause we got too many cops." Uh-uh, the opposite. They chart the relationship between how many cops you have and how many incidents of police violence you have. It's an inverse relationship. The countries with tons of cops have almost no examples of police brutality. The places that have almost no cops have a lot. Why? Makes perfect sense. When you are outnumbered, how do you project power? By using force.
David Remnick: What's called militarization.
Malcolm Gladwell: Exactly. Militarization is a response to the fact that you are scarce in number and you need to make a splash. Foucault could have told us this, right? The people who said, "Defund the police because they're too violent," have it absolutely backwards. Refund the police because they're too violent. They're outnumbered. I had a great--
David Remnick: How to reform the police?
Malcolm Gladwell: I had an incredibly fascinating conversation--
David Remnick: In other words, if the mayor of New York were sitting across the table from you, Zohran Mamdani were sitting across from you, and/or Jessica Tisch, who's the police commissioner, what would you urge them to do?
Malcolm Gladwell: New York is unusual in that it is closer to an adequate number of police officers than most American big cities. If you asked Jessica Tisch, "Do we have a magic wand?" she would say, "Could you take money away from the prisons and give them to the police?" She would say, "That is absolutely the best trade you could do." I talked to a guy who used to be a police chief from a big city in Colorado.
He was talking about, you look at your shifts. You can see, shift by shift, how long it takes for your officers to respond to a shooting. The sooner you get to the shooting, the better chance you have of apprehending the shooter, and also of saving the life of the person being shot. He can look and just say, "Well, at this time of night on a Tuesday, I just don't have the cops to cover it. They're coming from the other side of town. That person's going to die. We're not going to catch that."
He's like, "Really?" or I can't do the community outreach work. If I have enough cops, I can listen to the community. I can hear what their concerns are. These guys don't have to be in their squad car all day long, racing from one crime scene to the next. I want my police officers to know everyone in their precinct, to know all the trusted people, to have the kids so the kids can talk to them. All these things they want to do.
David Remnick: You write about disruption and de-escalation. How does that work in real life?
Malcolm Gladwell: Well, I was talking to Jens Ludwig when I did that New Yorker piece. I called up that guy Jens Ludwig. He was talking about he did a lot of work with the police in Chicago. He's like, "If you ride around at night with police officers, a lot of what they're doing is de-escalation." He's talked about one night, he was out with a cop. He sees a very, very large guy screaming at the top of his lungs and physically assaulting a woman, who's clearly his wife or girlfriend.
Cop stops, goes over there, says to the guy, "Go home. Calm down," tells the woman, "Come with me." What he did, did he prevent a potential homicide? Maybe. You don't know where that argument's going to go, right? That was his point that this is what police work is. The more police you have to engage in that kind of soft intervention, the better off your community's going to be. A lot of times, when people argue for more police, what they want is more arrests and more top-down aggression because that's the most politically appealing way to make that argument.
David Remnick: We're never going to get down to European levels or Canadian levels, no matter how good the policing gets, until there are just far fewer guns, no?
Malcolm Gladwell: I went to see a guy named David Kennedy a couple of days ago, a couple of weeks ago, who's, for years, been one of the most important figures in gun violence prevention in this country. He's a professor at John Jay. One of his comments was, "The fundamental misunderstanding of kids is they carry guns not because they're predatory, but because they're scared." They're scared. By the way, correctly, right?
In a world where the police are, into their eyes, absent and unconnected with the community, who's left to defend themselves? They are, right? One of the Baltimore meetings, I was-- I wrote about it. I have it in my podcast. They're talking about, they go and see a kid who they think is at risk for retaliating. A friend of his gets murdered. It's the latest in a whole chain of people he's lost. He's really, really, really, really upset. They go to him. A police officer and a pastor go and talk to him.
One of the first things they say is, "You have to trust that we can take care of this ourselves. We know who the shooter is." That's the first threshold. He thinks he's on his own, right? He's got to carry a gun because he thinks they're going to come by and get him. Anticipatory retaliation. That's the kind of dynamic there. You have to establish that the legitimate organizations are strong enough and effective enough. The kids don't have to be scared.
David Remnick: My friend, it's always great to see you. Malcolm Gladwell, thank you.
Malcolm Gladwell: Thank you, David.
[music]
David Remnick: Malcolm Gladwell's new book is called The American Way of Killing. He's also the host of the podcast Revisionist History, and you can find many years of Gladwell's writing for The New Yorker on our website. You can subscribe to the magazine there as well. You know how to do it. Newyorker.com. One word, newyorker.com.
[music]
Copyright © 2026 New York Public Radio. All rights reserved. Visit our website terms of use at www.wnyc.org for further information.
New York Public Radio transcripts are created on a rush deadline, often by contractors. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Accuracy and availability may vary. The authoritative record of New York Public Radio’s programming is the audio record.




