Announcer: Listener-supported WNYC Studios.
Intro: You're listening to Radiolab from WNYC.
Jordan: Hello, hello, hello.
Jad Abumrad: How do I want to introduce this tape to you? Have you heard this tape, Krulwich?
Robert Krulwich: I have not.
Jad: This actually one of my first radio pieces.
Jordan: You're not going to be able to hear what we're saying as we're in freefall.
Jad: I had two friends who were in love.
Speaker 4: I want to take a picture of the two of you suited up with your helmets on.
Jad: They've since fallen out of love and fallen in love with other people, but at the time, they were very much in love, and they had decided they were going to go skydiving.
Speaker 5: Everything looks good. You're ready for this?
Jordan: Yes, I guess so.
Speaker 5: Let's go skydiving.
Jad: This is my friend, Jordan. He is getting into a plane.
Speaker 5: All right. First, check your harness.
Jad: He's got a MiniDisc recorder strapped to his chest. I should just say that the piece ended up being really dumb, but it contains the best moment of tape I think I've ever recorded, and you're going to hear it coming up. As Jordan gets up into the sky, they're at like 7,000 or 8,000 feet, I don't remember the number, but they open the door--
Speaker 5: Okay, are you ready to skydive?
Jad: He steps just to the edge, and he's about to go-- You'll hear, there's going to be a moment, just listen.
Robert: Okay. [background noise]
Jad: He is out of the plane now, and he's hurling through space, free-falling. Within a few seconds, he's at 100 miles an hour- [background noise]
Jad: -up to 150-- 175 miles an hour- [background noise]
Jad: -maybe 200, I don't know, and- [background noise]
Speaker 5: Good job, how did you like that?
Jordan: [chuckles] It was incredible. Oh my God.
Jad: That's the moment where the parachute opens-
Jordan: I can not believe it.
Jad: -and he is floating.
Jordan: God, that's amazing.
Robert: What happened to the girl?
Jad: I don't know.
Robert: You don't know?
Jad: Well, her MiniDisc recorder malfunctioned on the way down. Let's just rewind that back for a second. [background noise]
Jordan: Whoa, damn.
Jad: That transition right there, from falling body to floating body, I love that because, at first, he sounds like this dinosaur falling through the air, but then the sound changes and it's just like, "Whoa." I don't know, it's like this moment of somebody falling out of control--
Robert: Then, falling back in.
Jad: Yes. It seemed like a good way to open the show, because this is going to be a show where we take this idea of falling--
Robert: And we walk it in all kinds of different directions.
Speaker 6: A point comes where you snap.
Robert: That's one-
Speaker 7: I loved him so much.
Jad: That's one-
Speaker 8: It's very dark. It's very hellish.
Robert: -and that's one.
Speaker 9: I was netting 81--
Jad: There are 14,932 ways to fall on the radio. In this hour, we'll bring you eight. I'm Jad Abumrad.
Robert: I'm Robert Krulwich.
Jad: This is Radiolab.
Robert: And we are falling. [music]
Jad: Number one.
Robert: This one is about-- I don't know, would you call it terror, or just--
Jad: No, it's about time, really.
Robert: Time, okay. We'll just call this one 'falling time'.
David Eagleman: Howdy.
Robert: This is David Eagleman.
David Eagleman: This is David here.
Robert: He's a neuroscientist, but back when he was a kid--
Jad: How old were you?
David Eagleman: I was eight years old.
Jad: He had an experience which he says changed his life. He was playing in his subdivision in Houston, and there was a house nearby--
David Eagleman: That was under construction, and my father told me not to go climbing around on the house under construction, but I was a boy, so I did. I was looking at the edge of the roof, and I stepped on it, but in fact, it was tarp paper hanging over the edge, and I fell.
Robert: Oh, so you stepped onto the air in effect. You just went, whoosh.
David Eagleman: Exactly. [music]
David Eagleman: What happened was, the event seemed to take a very long time. I thought about whether I had time to grab for the edge of the roof, and I realized it was too late for that. Then, I was looking down at the ground as the red-brick floor was coming towards me, and I was thinking about Alice in Wonderland, how this must be what it was like for her when she fell down the rabbit hole.
Robert: How long, by the way, was it from the top of the roof to the ground below?
David Eagleman: 0.86 seconds. That's how long it takes to fall 12 feet, I calculated that later.
Robert: [chuckles] I see.
Jad: That would be [inaudible 00:05:36] . This whole experience left David Eagleman with a question that he could not get out of his mind.
David Eagleman: What happens to people when they're in a life-or-death situation and they have these thoughts that seem to take a long time? At some point, I realized I needed to study this.
Jad: How would you even study that?
David Eagleman: The first thing I did, I took my entire laboratory to AstroWorld, which is the amusement park here in Houston, and we went on all of the scariest roller coasters. We brought all of our equipment and our stopwatches and had a great time, but it turns out, nothing there was scary enough to actually induce this fear for your life that appears to be required for the slow-motion effect. I searched around, and I finally found something called SCAD Diving.
Jad: SCAD Diving.
David Eagleman: It stands for suspended catch air device.
Jad: Where do you do that?
David Eagleman: Turns out it's illegal in Houston, but I found one in Dallas- [laughter]
David Eagleman: -so we made a road trip up to Dallas-
Speaker 10: All right, jump number one.
Jad: We actually found a reporter in Dallas who agreed to give this a try.
Speaker 10: You have to put the harness on, and then I'll put this on over the harness.
April: No one's ever died on this thing, right?
Speaker 10: No.
Jad: This is April.
April: I feel like my heart's in my throat.
Jad: She's very brave.
David Eagleman: You ride up to the top of this tower in this very rickety little elevator-type-of-thing.
April: We're rising up in the elevator right now.
David Eagleman: 150-foot tall tower, climbing up, and up, and up.
April: It doesn't seem that far when you're down there. Up here, it seems really far.
David Eagleman: It's like a 15-story building.
Speaker 10: We're halfway.
April: Halfway. [chuckles] This is just halfway, I'm already freaking out. My hands are starting to shake.
David Eagleman: At the very top, you're suspended.
April: Like this?
Speaker 10: Yes.
David Eagleman: You're hooked up to a carabiner.
April: Oh, God.
Speaker 10: Sit all the way back, lean back.
Robert: Okay, I want you to imagine this, you're up in the sky, you're facing the clouds, not the ground, you're attached to something which is about to be severed, and you will fall totally free into the void, unable to see what's about to happen to you, presuming a net, maybe.
April: Oh, God. Okay. Don't let me die.
Jad: Three, two--
April: Really nervous right now-- [screams]
Jad: Okay, wait, one thing I forgot to mention. April actually wasn't part of David's study, but if she had been, she would have been wearing, around her wrist, this little device.
David Eagleman: A new device called the perceptual chronometer.
Jad: It's about the size of a watch, and it flashes numbers super fast. Way too fast to see normally. The thought is, if April falls and everything starts to slow down, then these numbers should slow too, so that if she looks at her wrist as she's falling, she should be able--
David Eagleman: To now read the watch. That would be impossible under normal circumstances.
Jad: Back to April.
April: Really nervous right now.
Jad: Three, two, and--
April: [screams] Oh my God. Oh my God. Oh my God, this is the scariest moment in my life. [chuckles] Oh my God.
David Eagleman: I should probably tell you guys the results of this study, but [crosstalk] --
Jad: Yes, did people report that time slowed down enough for them to read the number?
David Eagleman: No.
David Eagleman: Turns out, when you're falling, you don't actually see in slow-motion.
David Eagleman: Yes, it's not equivalent to the way a slow-motion camera would work. Even though people feel like it's going in slow-motion, it's something more interesting than that.
Jad: Because here's the thing, right after people did the jump, he would ask them--
David Eagleman: How long they thought their fall took.
Jad: The right answer, if they had a stopwatch--
David Eagleman: Just under three seconds.
Jad: But what people would say--
Speaker 11: When you were falling, how long did it--
Speaker 12: 10 seconds.It felt like time had stopped.
Jad: How do you explain that? Time's not slowing in the moment, but seems to be slowing after the moment?
David Eagleman: Well, I came to understand that it's a trick of memory. Normally, our memories are like sieves. We're not writing down most of what's passing through our system.
Jad: But he thinks that when you go-- [person screaming] -- Life-or-death moment-
April: Oh my God.
Jad: -in that instant, our memories go wide open.
David Eagleman: Because that's what memory is for. It's for when everything hits the fan, you want to write it down and remember it.
Jad: So all of it goes right to your hard drive. The clouds, the feeling of the air, "Oh, look there's a guy in a blue shirt."
David Eagleman: When you read that back out, the experience feels like it must have taken a very long time. It must have.
Robert: Normally, the trivial stuff gets dumped, but in this situation, it gets written.
Jad: Then you realize how much trivial stuff is in there.
David Eagleman: For example, I just recently interviewed a gentleman who had been in a motorcycle accident, and as his helmet was bouncing along off the asphalt, he was composing a little song to the rhythm of his helmet bouncing. [laughter]
Robert: Was he in his helmet or had the helmet flown off?
David Eagleman: Yes, he was in his helmet.
Jad: Before I [unintelligible 00:10:44] too loudly, was he okay as a result of this bouncing?
David Eagleman: Yes, he was okay.
Jad: Wow, that's amazing. His head was going thump, thump, thump, and he's like, "Hey, that's a good rhythm."
Speaker 13: Oh, my, what a peculiar place to have a party. [music]
Speaker 13: Goodness, what if I could fall right through the center of earth-- [music]
Jad: Number two, falling in love from Producer Lulu Miller. Set this up for us.
Lulu Miller: Well, this is a love story, and in some ways, it's a very typical love story. In other ways, it's--
Robert: Just not.
Lulu Miller: Yes. The girl is a really good friend of mine. We're going to call her Sarita, and the boy we'll call Simon. When was the first time that you ever saw Simon?
Sarita: I don't remember the exact moment, but I do remember sitting in the lunchroom with the girls at the table and scooping out the boys. He was definitely the skinniest. He just looked like a really nice guy. Olive-skinned, thick hair, and he made really good eye contact to the point where it's a little flirty. There's no break in the eye contact. It's like constant, to the point where I think it could be uncomfortable for some people, but I just really liked it. [music]
Lulu Miller: When was the first time you talked to him?
Sarita: Well, we had a class together our freshman year. We talked a lot in class, and after class, on the paths around campus--
Lulu Miller: And that's how it went all freshman year-
Sarita: Sophomore year-
Lulu Miller: -junior year-
Lulu Miller: They were sort of like particles that just kept colliding--
Sarita: In the lobby of the dorm, on the sidewalk, and each time it was new. A new topic or a new idea.
Lulu Miller: For instance, one of them would walk by carrying a book-
Sarita: [unintelligible 00:13:11] bible.
Lulu Miller: -and the other one would say, "Oh, I love that book."
Lulu Miller: They just clicked.
Sarita: Again, the eye contact. We would talk and be connected with the eyes. That's what I really was falling for about him, there was like an attentiveness beyond--
Lulu Miller: I want to ask you one thing which-- You just said, "I'm falling for him," is that the way it felt? People always say falling in love, did it feel like falling?
Sarita: Yes. It does because it feels out of control. There's a moment where it feels like I let go and allow myself to feel it totally.
Lulu Miller: Though there were some moments where she wondered if she should.
Lulu Miller: Like sometimes, she'd walk by Simon on the path, look up and smile--
Sarita: [unintelligible 00:14:09] me.
Lulu Miller: But then--
Sarita: We run into each other, and we talk--
Lulu Miller: She'd let herself start falling again.
Sarita: This is really fun in this moment. I realized years later that every time we ran into each other, he has no idea that those were me.
Lulu Miller: Really?
Lulu Miller: Hi.
Lulu Miller: Could you hear me vaguely? [chuckles]
Lulu Miller: Can we start out talking about your condition?
Lulu Miller: What's it called?
Lulu Miller: Prosopagnosia sounds like a delicious fruit salad.
Simon: It could be a cocktail.
Lulu Miller: What is that word?
Simon: Let's see-- Well, agnosia is a lack or an inability, and proso is the Greek for face. Face blindness.
Lulu Miller: This, of course, is Simon.
Simon: There's a little piece in my brain that's missing. I have a really, really hard time recognizing faces, remembering faces.
Lulu Miller: How does that work? Is it just that you forget where you know people from?
Simon: No. If I passed you in the street, I can't swear that I've ever seen you before.
Lulu Miller: So he didn't know. He couldn't string those together as all the same person having the same conversation.
Simon: Right, no way.
Lulu Miller: Even their first kiss, he didn't realize he was kissing a girl he'd actually known for years.
Simon: [chuckles] Yes.
Lulu Miller: Were you totally shocked?
Sarita: I was totally blown away.
Lulu Miller: Who was that person to you?
Simon: I knew it was the cheese-plate girl. I did not know it was field-house girl
Lulu Miller: What did you say?
Sarita: I think I just asked a lot of questions.
Simon: She was interested, "How does this work?" I probably said, "If you went to the park and started looking at trees, their shapes are different, their sizes are different, but to try and remember 1,000 or 2,000 of those--"
Sarita: How do you pick it out?
Simon: It's just hard. It's just computationally difficult.
Lulu Miller: What details did you know about her?
Simon: I knew it was good to be with her. The experience of being with her I think ran ahead of my sense of her biography. It was a leap.
Lulu Miller: It was a leap.
Simon: Yes. Let's try this--
Lulu Miller: They embark on this relationship, which has its quirks.
Lulu Miller: For instance, if they were meeting up somewhere public--
Sarita: I'm going to need to wave first, and backpacks, he's always got to wear the same one.
Simon: Voice really helps.
Sarita: I would get a little bit anxious when we'd have to meet each other somewhere, because I knew if another curly-haired girl walked there before I did-
Simon: I'm thinking, is that her?
Sarita: -he would smile and wave at her. [laughs]
Simon: It's just awkward. It's just embarrassing.
Lulu Miller: Somewhere along the line, Sarita found out that that eye contact that drew her in, it wasn't really about her. It was something he did--
Sarita: With everyone, on the off-chance that they're his friend. That's what I think the eye contact is.
Lulu Miller: Did that make you step back at all?
Sarita: No. By then, I had already fell.
Lulu Miller: Plus, Sarita at that time was getting really into Buddhism. Not just a little bit, she went and lived with Buddhist nuns for a year in Sri Lanka.
Sarita: The idea of impermanence, and-- We think we have a self, but what really is a self, what it means to know someone? All of that was part of my world, and so this idea that he didn't recognize me didn't seem as important as the present moment.
Simon: It just kept getting better.
Lulu Miller: Then what happened? You graduated, then did you move in together?
Lulu Miller: Was it in Philly?
Sarita: It was in Philly, on Sansom Street.
Lulu Miller: A year and a half goes by, and then one day--
Simon: I woke up and, swear to God, like all the leaves fell off the trees. Fall turned into winter.
Lulu Miller: And Simon told Sarita it was over.
Sarita: Something about a core that I'm lacking.
Lulu Miller: He said you were lacking a core?
Lulu Miller: What does that mean?
Sarita: I don't know. I'm not sure what it means.
Simon: Good God, I knew the core would come up. The core-- What I was trying to talk about was lingering doubt, whether this was it. Wondering, could I fall further?
Sarita: He just wasn't sure that he loved me, and then at that point, kind of backtracked and denied having ever really loved me. That's how it was.
Lulu Miller: Did you feel like you, at a certain point, started to actually fall out of love with him?
Sarita: No. There was no falling. It was just like I was at the bottom of a well sitting and stewing. I loved him so much.
Lulu Miller: Would you see him in the neighborhood? Because you're still neighbors, right?
Sarita: Yes. We would see each other around at parties. He was working at a restaurant that had an outdoor patio, and I walked by there a few times without him knowing it was me. Where I could see him and look at him--
Lulu Miller: But you got to just be hidden.
Sarita: Yes. I got to just walk by, so there is comfort in that.
Simon: I didn't know that. Yes, it's hard somehow, that I wouldn't see her. It's like she faded back into the crowd quickly.
Sarita: I had become lost.
Simon: It's actually haunting to me, to hear that. [music]
Announcer: We'll be right back.
Lulu Miller: Oh, that message is still there. Hi, it's Lulu calling with the credits. Radiolab is supported in part by the National Science Foundation and the Alfred P. Sloan Foundation, enhancing public understanding of science and technology in the modern world. More information about Sloan at www.sloan.org. Radiolab is produced by WNYC [unintelligible 00:22:09] this message.
Announcer: Science reporting on Radiolab is supported in part by Science Sandbox, a Simons Foundation initiative dedicated to engaging everyone with the process of science.
Jad: Hey, this is Jad. Radiolab is supported by Avast. Avast is a global leader in cybersecurity, trusted by over 435 million users. Avast has privacy solutions to keep your identity and actions hidden, security solutions to stop malware, phishing, and virus attacks, and performance-enhancing solutions to clean up and speed up your devices. Avast empowers you to feel safer, private, and more confident online to do what you want to do in your connected life. Shop, work, browse confidently on all your devices. Learn more about Avast privacy, security, and performance products at avast.com.
Jim O'Grady: The September 11th terrorist attacks changed the world. There's a sense that they came out of nowhere, they didn't. I'm Jim O'Grady, and in my new podcast, I'm going to revisit the evidence and question the people at the center of the story.
Speaker 15: I don't want to use the word panic. Let's penetrate his cell--
Speaker 16: -and I promised him revenge.
Jim O'Grady: Blindspot: The Road to 9/11, a new podcast series from History and WNYC Studios. Listen, wherever you get your podcast.
Jad: Hey, I'm Jad Abumrad.
Robert: I'm Robert Krulwich.
Jad: This is Radiolab, and today-- Today, we're falling in many different flavors, and we're at number three.
Robert: Next, we have the story of a different kind of fall-
Jad: All right.
Robert: -or faller-
Jad: -comes from science writer, David Quammen.
Robert: One article in particular that he wrote, caught our attention. All right, I'm going to quote you to yourself.
David Quammen: Okay.
Robert: Nowadays, [unintelligible 00:23:56] , we know quite a bit about cats, they've been dissected in uncountable numbers. Their anatomy, their physiology, their behavior, have been minutely studied, but there's so much we still don't know. Among all the other intractable issues, one in particular interests me, and that is, what's the terminal velocity of a plummeting cat?
Jad: Why-- Can you give me a little history, why did that question interest you?
David Quammen: I mean, when I used to write for Outside Magazine, I would browse through journals, and I would come across obscure papers. How I happened upon the Journal of the American Veterinary Medical Association, familiarly known as JAVMA, I don't know. I don't remember, but I'm sure that that was the starting point.
Robert: Because it was in that journal that David ran across a research paper by two vets--
David Quammen: Wayne Whitney and Cheryl Mehlhaff--
Robert: Who worked in--
David Quammen: The Midtown Veterinary Hospital.
Robert: And they noticed that in Manhattan--
David Quammen: There were a lot of cats falling out of high windows, falling off ledges, falling off roofs--
Jad: What is a lot? I mean, how many cats were coming into this place?
Ann Hohenhaus: We saw 132 cats fall in a five-month summer period.
Robert: That's Ann Hohenhaus. She actually works in the veterinary hospital-
Ann Hohenhaus: Right here at the Animal Medical Center.
Robert: -and she's been there since that research paper was written back in 1986.
Ann Hohenhaus: When I came to New York City, I said, "What do you mean cats fall out of buildings? It doesn't make sense. Why would the cat fall out?"
Robert: But we'll get back to her in just a little bit.
David Quammen: 132 in five months, that's almost a rain of cats.
Robert: Well, no, don't say that, because I think people should visit New York cat-receiving umbrellas--
Jad: Five, eight, two--
Robert: What are you doing?
Jad: I'm doing the math to see how many that is in a week of-- [laughter]
David Quammen: 35 days, it's about--
Jad: Jeez, that's about a cat a day.
Robert: It's a shame we can only be about that.
Jad: But according to David, it's actually not as much of a shame as you would think.
David Quammen: 22 of the cats that they saw had fallen from eight stories or higher, and out of those 22, only one died. 21 cats survived from eight stories or higher.
Jad: Wow, that's a long way.
David Quammen: There was one cat that fell 32 stories, and the cat had a little bit of sort of thoracic bruising and a chipped tooth, and that was it.
Jad: I mean, how in the world do cats-- I mean, we all know cats land on their feet, yes, but how do they do that? Like these are not magical creatures.
Robert: Well, if you go back about 1,000 years--
David Quammen: It was thought that they consorted with witches, with the devil, and their reputation got darker and darker. The more people started to distrust and dislike cats, the more they started to do horrible things to them. They would put cats in a barrel and then they [unintelligible 00:26:45] the barrel through with swords. Also, throwing them out of windows, the defenestration of cats.
Jad: What does the defenestration mean?
Robert: Throwing out the window. Fenestra is a window, so if you de--
Jad: Really, there's a word for that?
David Quammen: Jad, add that to your active vocabulary today.
Jad: I plan to. What would happen when they would defenestrate these cats?
David Quammen: The cats would land on their feet and walk away, and that made people even crazier. [music]
Jad: No, of course, we love our cats now. We don't do that to our cats anymore.
Robert: But when we went to visit Ann back at the veterinary hospital, we were asking her about the falling cats research paper, which was called The Feline High-rise--
Jad: The Feline High-rise Syndrome.
Robert: Then, the mystery of how cats can fall from these amazing heights and survive, got a lot deeper.
Ann Hohenhaus: Well, cats that fell less than five stories--
Robert: They did fine, she said.
Ann Hohenhaus: Not too bad. Cats that fell over nine stories--
Robert: They did fine too, she says.
Ann Hohenhaus: Not so bad.
Robert: Which is weird, but--
Ann Hohenhaus: Cats that fell between five and nine-
Robert: Between five floors and nine floors--
Ann Hohenhaus: -had really serious injuries, and had more injuries per cat.
Jad: Cats that fell a little way we're okay, cats that fell a long way we're okay, weirdly, but this five to nine thing--
Robert: Yes, how do you account for that?
Ann Hohenhaus: We had to get a physicist to help us explain this.
Robert: This is where we get back to what Quammen calls--
David Quammen: The terminal velocity issue.
Jad: Here's how Ann put it to us--
Robert: Say you're living on the 30th floor of a building, and it's summertime--
Ann Hohenhaus: You get done at work at 5:00, you go home, get there about 6:00. The apartment's hot and stuffy, and you open up those windows, and Fluffy says, "Hmm, I'd like that pigeon out there." The next thing you know, a misstep, and-- [cat meowing] As the cat starts to fall, he's all disoriented.
Jad: And almost immediately--
David Quammen: Probably within the first six feet--
Ann Hohenhaus: The cat's brain says, "Okay, turn your front half over. Now bring your back legs around--"
Robert: That's like instinct.
David Quammen: A cat can apparently do that move lickety-split.
Robert: But the cat is still speeding up.
Ann Hohenhaus: Going faster and faster.
Jad: Three floors, five floors, seven floors.
Robert: After falling about nine floors--
Jad: And accelerating to speeds--
David Quammen: Up to about 60 miles an hour--
Jad: Something happens.
David Quammen: You hit an equilibrium between the pull of gravity and wind resistance.
Jad: What it means is gravity is pulling down on you, and the peak pull is between five and nine floors for a cat, but after nine floors, the wind resistance which all the while has been pushing back up on you, starts to slow you down.
David Quammen: You don't speed up anymore.
Robert: That's your cruising speed.
David Quammen: That's your cruising speed. After the cats hit terminal velocity and the sensation of acceleration was gone, they relaxed. They sort of stretch out like a flying squirrel, and then they hit the ground, belly flop.
Jad: And you're saying that because they hit this cruising speed, and then relaxed [unintelligible 00:29:48] the flying squirrel, the impact is less?
David Quammen: Yes.
Ann Hohenhaus: Yes, and in our record here-- It wasn't in this paper, but our record is 42 floors and the cat walked away.
Robert: 42 floors--
Jad: Is that a lucky cat or is that just plain physics? Should cats everywhere go to the 42nd floor before jumping out of the window?
Ann Hohenhaus: No cat should ever jump out of a window.
Jad: That's right, stay indoors. [cat meowing] No, Fluffy, back. [music]
Jad: The next falling, what are we going to call this? Falling--
Robert: Falling episodes?
Jad: Is there an F-word we could use?
Jad: Yes, great.
Robert: Our next falling feature, we invited Columbia University physics professor, Brian Greene, into our studio.
Brian Greene: Do I get to play with any buttons?
Robert: We wanted to ask him-- Well, really one of the most basic questions you could ask a physicist--
Jad: Why do we fall?
Brian Greene: We all know that Newton wrote down a law of gravity to calculate how gravity acts from one object to another.
Jad: Yes, like if you drop your pen.
Brian Greene: That's right, but there's a difference between being able to predict what will happen and be able to explain why it happens. Newton could not explain why it happens. He could only tell you what would happen.
Jad: But I mean, how it works is it just pulls the pen down.
Brian Greene: What does that mean though? How does it pull it? I don't see anything between the table and your pen, so what is the agent responsible for the pull?
Robert: This is something even Albert Einstein himself couldn't quite figure out.
Brian Greene: He was struggling to understand how the force of gravity works. It was a big, big puzzle.
Robert: The legend goes that Albert Einstein was walking around one day, and he found himself imagining a person riding in an elevator. All of a sudden, the cable gets cut and the elevator starts a plunge right down towards the earth.
Jad: The version I know is that he was actually sitting at his desk looking out the window, and he was imagining window washers falling from their scaffolding, but it's the same exact idea.
Robert: Anyway, we're going to stick with the elevator version for now. Einstein imagined this person standing actually on a bathroom scale in the elevator, this is before the cable gets cut.
Brian Greene: If the person is in the elevator standing on a scale, they see that they weigh 160 pounds.
Robert: Then, snip--
Brian Greene: When the elevator cable is cut, they look down at the scale and the scale will drop to zero, because the scale will be falling away from their feet at exactly the same rate that their feet are falling. Their feet won't push on the scale any longer because the scale will be moving downward with them.
Jad: In my mind, I imagined like a Hollywood movie where it's falling so fast, everybody kind of drifts up almost.
Brian Greene: That's right. Einstein said to himself, "Hang on a second, here's an environment where, in essence, I can turn gravity off." Another way of saying it that flips it around and may make it more clear, just as you can turn gravity off by snapping the cable, you can actually simulate gravity by pulling on the cable that pulls that elevator up really, really quickly, because now the scale is running into your feet. If you're standing on that scale, it won't read 160, it might read 250.
Jad: It seems like gravity and being pulled up really fast, they're the same thing.
Brian Greene: They are.
Robert: Jad, look at you, you just had the insight on your own.
Brian Greene: That's right.
Jad: He walked us 17 steps and I just made the last baby step.
Brian Greene: You did it. Whenever you're faced with a gravitational problem, this allowed you to ignore gravity and translate it into a problem about motion.
Jad: Does that solve the 'what is gravity' question? It just sorts of--
Brian Greene: No, he then had to make one more leap, and it's not obvious how he took the final step, but the final step was to realize that the 'what is gravity' is the curvature of space and time. That's a leap.
Jad: I don't know what that means.
Robert: Well, this is a very difficult concept--
Jad: Do you understand it?
Robert: I understand what Einstein tells you when he explained it. He said, if you imagine the universe as a vast rubber mat, a rubber mat held really, really taut, let's just take-- I don't know, let's take the earth and just plop it onto the mat. What just happened?
Jad: Well, it sunk into the rubber.
Robert: It stretched the rubber, didn't it?
Robert: So the rubber is kind of curved around underneath it. In Einstein's mind, he thought, "Maybe this is how to explain gravity. This is what gravity is."
Brian Greene: That curved shape of space, he said, and the pen falls because it's following a contour in that curved spacetime environment.
Jad: Oh, so if we're living on the curve, then we're constantly falling down that contour.
Robert: We're [crosstalk] moving down that curve, yes. We have no choice.
Brian Greene: The reason why right now I feel the chair pushing up on me is, again, my body also wants to slide down, but the chairs getting in the way.
Jad: So we're all sort of on some kind of slope sliding down, unless we're--
Brian Greene: Yes, that's right.
Jad: I like that. I'm now an adherent to that theory, not knowing anything else. Now, for number five, should we call it falling fortunes or--?
Robert: Falling fortunes is a good one for this, I think, because someone is seeking fame and fortune, and then--
Garrett Soden: The idea of the gravity hero, to me, one of the things that-- It goes along with--
Jad: Was that a term that was used, gravity heroes?
Garrett Soden: No, that's my term.
Jad: I like it though. It's a really catchy term.
Garrett Soden: Well, thanks.
Jad: This is Garrett Soden, he's an author.
Garrett Soden: Author of Defying Gravity-
Jad: Original title.
Garrett Soden: -Falling: How our Greatest Fear Became our Greatest Thrill- A History.
Jad: Speaking of history, and fears, and thrills, and I would add to that list, tragedy, he tells the following story--
Garrett Soden: It really started with Niagara Falls, because up to that point, people had done all kinds of things at Niagara Falls.
Jad: To back up, it is the 1850s, and at Niagara Falls, you've got these two guys doing tightrope tricks over the falls. A fellow named Charles Blondin-
Garrett Soden: Famous French wire-walker.
Jad: -and a Canadian guy who called himself--
Garrett Soden: The Great Farini.
Jad: -and they would duke it out.
Garrett Soden: Right. Blondin came out, strung a rope across Niagara Falls, put a chair down balanced on two legs, and stood on it. One time, he carried a guy over-- He had to keep upping the ante, so--
Jad: For his greatest trick--
Garrett Soden: He carried a small cast iron stove on his back with some firewood. He got out there and he put the stove down, lit a fire, had a couple of eggs and a frying pan, and made an omelet--
Jad: Right over this churning rapid?
Garrett Soden: Yes.
Garrett Soden: The Great Farini came out with a washing machine, that was his answer to Blondin, wash some clothes out there.
Jad: The thing to know about these guys is this was basically just a show, because-- For example, the wire that they walked on was pretty wide.
Garrett Soden: About the diameter of a coffee cup.
Jad: Really, they were just avoiding the big trick.
Garrett Soden: The most anticipated trick-
Jad: The one that everybody was waiting for.
Garrett Soden: -was somebody going over the falls in a barrel.
Jad: The guy who did that would be the real gravity hero, you wire-walking wussies. Niagara Falls is one of the great forces of nature. Every second, 600,000 gallons fall over the edge, pound the rocks below was such a fury that you can hear it five miles away. Which is why in 1850, when P.T. Barnum saw the falls--
Joan Murray: He said that if someone could figure out a way to go over that, that would be a huge stunt that would give them fame and fortune.
Jad: That's Joan Murray--
Joan Murray: I'm a poet.
Jad: She's a poet. She's written in a whole book-
Joan Murray: -and verse-
Jad: -about the first person to conquer the falls-
Joan Murray: In a barrel.
Jad: -and it's called--
Joan Murray: Queen of the Mist.
Robert: Queen of the Mist, so it wasn't a guy then.
Jad: No, I just said it was a guy to set you up so that you would ask me that question, because in fact, it was a woman.
Robert: Wow. Props to her.
Jad: Thank you for acting surprised.
Robert: What's her name, Jad?
Joan Murray: Annie Taylor.
Jad: When we first meet Annie Taylor--
Joan Murray: This was 1901.
Jad: -she was-
Joan Murray: Down on her luck.
Robert: She'd done a lot of different things. She had run a dancing school, she had been a principal, she had traveled all over the world.
Jad: Her only child had died, her husband, right after that, and she was broke, but then it hit her. She was sitting at home-
Robert: Sitting in her apartment-
Jad: -in Bay City, Michigan.
Robert: -and for some odd reason, she read an article about the goings-on at Niagara Falls, and she decided she would go over Niagara Falls in a barrel.
Jad: Why? I mean, do we know?
Joan Murray: She's looking to save herself from the poorhouse.
Robert: She was after money.
Jad: When she read about these guys at Niagara Falls, she thought, "This is it."
Robert: Right, so she called a cooper to build the barrel. At first, he refused to build it when he heard what her plan was, but finally, he did.
Jad: Not long after, Annie was on a train with her barrel headed to the falls. By the way, what day are we talking about? Just so we have a date [crosstalk]
Joan Murray: On October 24th in 1901.
Robert: Word had spread--
Jad: This was going to be a spectacle.
Joan Murray: Everyone was there.
Robert: Mobs of people-
Robert: -up and down the river.
Jad: Tens of thousands, and Annie shows up-
Joan Murray: -waving to the crowd.
Jad: Wearing a very fancy Victorian dress-
Joan Murray: -and a hat with ostrich feathers. She's quite the lady, but then they go on an island where she changes-
Jad: -into some gym clothes.
Joan Murray: Now, she gets in the barrel.
Jad: They tow her out to the middle of the river-
Joan Murray: -then they knock [knocking sound] and cut the rope, and off she goes to the brink.
Robert: The roar of the river-
Joan Murray: -enormous. It's wet at my feet, and I'm feeling while I'm in there that this is miserable--
Jad: The interesting thing is that in Joan's poem, she actually becomes Annie.
Joan Murray: I careened and spun--
Jad: She's in the barrel getting hurled down the river, tossed, and turned. Joan Murray: [unintelligible 00:40:09] .
Jad: As she gets closer to the edge, just about a half-mile journey, she begins to hallucinate.
Joan Murray: I glimpse through the turbulence, there was my young husband. In his arms, our baby trembling and whimpering as [inaudible 00:40:24]
Jad: And then--
Robert: This moment of weightlessness.
Joan Murray: She's going-
Jad: -down, into the pools below.
Robert: The great mass of foam, and boiling water.
Jad: Then, she shoots out again-
Robert: -through the buoyancy of the barrel, about 15 feet in the air.
Jad: The barrel crashes back-
Robert: Back down on the water.
Jad: -and then, it floats over to some rocks, and a rescue team paddled out to the barrel right away.
Robert: They get the barrel, and they have to saw it open.
Jad: The crowd no doubt is thinking, “That woman is dead. There's nothing, but a dead woman in that barrel.”
Joan Murray: But-
Jad: -when they pull her out-
Joan Murray: -she’s alive, "I am alive." She took on this thing that the world was waiting for. She did it, she was the first to ever try.
Jad: Joan, when she was pulled out of that barrel, and presumably, she's going to take the next step into fame, and fortune, what happened?
Joan Murray: More or less, nothing. She stepped out of the barrel, and she didn't look right. She didn't look like a hero.
Robert: What does that mean?
Jad: Well, I've kept something from you, Krulwich.
Jad: The thing I haven't told you is that, not only was she wet and soggy, and according to newspaper accounts, hysterical-- I mean, who wouldn't be? She was 63.
Joan Murray: She was your grandmother.
Jad: She was an older lady. Like Joan said, for the hero-consuming public, she just didn't look right
Robert: After that exhibition, her manager ran off with the barrel. He took the barrel, and he started going on the circuit with a lovely young woman that he claimed was Annie Taylor.
Robert: Much better showpiece. What happened to Annie though?
Joan Murray: She would drag herself to Niagara each spring and summer--
Robert: She would just sit on the street with a barrel. It wasn't the original barrel, but it was a barrel.
Jad: And do what?
Robert: She probably had photographs of herself that she signed.
Jad: Did she ever make any money off this?
Joan Murray: No, she died in a poorhouse.
Robert: Which is where she didn't want to wind up, but that is where she wound up.
Jad: Just 10 years later, somebody repeats Annie’s feat.
Joan Murray: A man, and he tours the world.
Joan Murray: Yes, bastard.
Joan Murray: -because the heavens are merciful-
Jad: -during this guy's victory lap as he’s traveling around the world-
Joan Murray: -he slipped on an orange rind in Australia, or New Zealand, got a compound fracture of his leg.
Jad: She says that leg got gangrene, and he died.
Joan Murray: Yes. There is cosmic justice. [music] [snoring sounds]
Jad: Are you asleep? Hey.
Jad: Do you even know where you are right now?
Robert: Did you see what I did with my leg?
Robert: I kicked myself awake, did you see that?
Jad: I heard it. I'm Jad Abumrad.
Robert: I'm Robert Krulwich.
Jad: Our next falling feature is--
Robert: Is falling asleep, but with a little kick.
Jad: This is Radiolab.
Frederick Coolidge: Let's do it.
Jad: Tell me your name first, and tell me how you would like to be identified on air.
Frederick Coolidge: You can call me Fred, I like it the best. My full title is Professor Frederick L. Coolidge, University of Colorado at Colorado Springs.
Jad: Just so we get our definitions right, what is a hypnic jerk?
Frederick Coolidge: It appears to be this-- What seems to be a reflex, everybody's experienced it. It's, you're still semi-conscious, then you start to feel dreamy. You start to feel this loosening of your thoughts, loosening of your reality.
Jad: But just as you're about to go under, he says--
Frederick Coolidge: Just at the first onset of sleep, bam, one big jerk.
Jad: Then you're-
Frederick Coolidge: -awake.
Jad: Usually, you wake up with this feeling of like, "Oh, my God. Oh, my God. Oh, my god. Oh, all right." How did you start studying this?
Frederick Coolidge: I was working at Kentucky Fried Chicken-- Can I say it on the air?
Frederick Coolidge: For $1 an hour, and I just thought, "Man--" I still can't eat coleslaw to this day, because I would do 100 pounds of coleslaw a day. I saw this ad on campus, and it said, "Somebody to work in a sleep lab," so I went and applied. I ended up in the beginning cleaning toilets, but I just got into all [unintelligible 00:45:54] . I thought it was fascinating. I got fascinated by these giant jerks at the beginning of sleep, and I said, "What is that?" They said, "Oh, that's a hypnic jerk." I said, "What is that?" They said, "That's a hypnic jerk."
Jad: In other words, no one could really explain to him why these things happen.
Frederick Coolidge: That's right.
Jad: He started poking around, and there were some theories having to do with physiological changes in your body.
Frederick Coolidge: A lowering of oxygen content or something like this.
Jad: But that kind of explanation didn't really satisfy.
Frederick Coolidge: It really doesn't say why, what was its function? As I started to look at the literature, I saw that we had a very long history sleeping in trees. If we go back to Australopithecus afarensis, this is Lucy, 3 million years ago. Lucy was bipedal. I mean, walking on two legs.
Jad: Lucy lived in the trees, but unlike the other primates, she would sometimes go down to the ground.
Frederick Coolidge: But on the ground, you've got big birds, you've got snakes, tigers, and reptiles. That ground life was stressful but, at night, she crawled up the tree for safety. She climbs up in that tree, drops food there for her baby, and she's going to drop off to sleep.
Jad: Her muscles loosen, her hands uncurl.
Frederick Coolidge: She starts to have that relaxation.
Jad: Pretty soon, she can't feel the tree under her back, or hear the noises down below.
Jad: Stay with me, Krulwich.
Jad: She feels like she's floating, or falling.
Frederick Coolidge: Lucy, falling, falling--
Jad: That means-- [animal growling]
Frederick Coolidge: It may be a real good idea to wake up from that. Sleep was such a dangerous proposition for so many millions of years that something like the hypnic jerk, if some of those primates had that behavior, they may have been just slightly more likely over millions of years to adapt and survive.
Jad: We haven't gotten rid of it yet, is what he's saying.
Robert: That's my trick, is just basically so I don't get eaten by a lion all these many years [crosstalk] ?
Jad: Yes, that's what he's saying. It's sort of like a Lucy echo.
Robert: Do we know this, or are we just imagining--?
Jad: No, how are we going to know this? This is just a story, but there's at least one tantalizing bit of evidence to support this idea.
Frederick Coolidge: You ask college students, what are the most common dreams that you have? Falling is number one or number two most common theme. If you go on a college campus, thanks to OSHA, you have no chance of falling off anything. They'll make sure that [unintelligible 00:48:28] drop is like a foot or six inches. Even then, it'd have big yellow and red signs all over it, but they dream of falling? What?
Jad: By the way, the next most common dream after falling is being chased by an alien in a blue dress.
Robert: No, it isn't. [music]
Jad: [unintelligible 00:48:47] . [music]
Speaker 18: You're walking, and you don't always realize it, but you're always falling.
David Eagleman: Actually, I have a random one for you guys about falling. As I was driving over here, I was thinking about it.
Speaker 18: With each step-
Jad: Neuroscientist David Eagleman again.
Speaker 18: -you fall forward slightly, and then catch yourself.
David Eagleman: I started wondering, what happens-- Why is it that elderly people fall down a lot? If you go into any hospital ward, you'll see lots and lots of elderly people who are in there with broken hips and things like that because they've fallen. I started asking my clinician friends, and they say, "Well, they have a poor sense of balance, muscle weakness," and so on. I said, "Could it have anything to do with timing?"
Jad: What do you mean?
David Eagleman: Well, one of the things I study is how the brain sends out signals to the whole body, and how these signals come back. Because the strange part is, the brain is situated all the way at one end of the body, all the way at the top end, and it's controlling this huge amount of machinery. You have to send signals all the way out to the toes and all the way back, and they're surprisingly slow in the brain. It's about 300,000 times slower than signals move around in a computer. It would be like if you were a NASA operator controlling the Mars Rover, there's a delay between when you send the signals and when you get the feedback. What happens is the brain puts a lot of effort into making sure that it knows exactly the timing of sending signals out and when it's getting signals back, and that's how you walk, for example.
Speaker 19: Do you want the camera? Caty, get the camera.
Robert: This is like what toddlers learn in reverse? Aren't they learning the timings to get the left foot out in front of the right?
David Eagleman: That's exactly what they're doing. They're calibrating the timing of their whole nervous system.
Jad: That's interesting, because my kid's 10 months old, and I think he's in this calibrating period. What's happening with him now is he's standing, but then it looks like he's about to take a step, but then, [unintelligible 00:51:52] -- Oh, thud.
Robert: [unintelligible 00:51:55] .
Jad: Basically, you're saying his little brain is trying to figure out the timings of electricity racing from brain to foot and foot back to brain.
David Eagleman: Yes.
Jad: Mission control is going-- [beep] "Okay, we're sending that message to the feet. We expect it back in 300 milisec--" [gasps] tumble fall.
Speaker 19: Oh, take three.
Jad: Okay, we're going to try now 280 milliseconds. 280, go. [unintelligible 00:52:22] -- [gasps] tumble fall.
David Eagleman: That's exactly right. A lot of trial and error until you get the timing right.
Robert: But get it right, now you're a walker.
David Eagleman: Right.
Speaker 19: Three, four, [unintelligible 00:52:32] -- Oh my God, you're like running.
David Eagleman: Now, something that happens in, let's say, multiple sclerosis-
Jad: And maybe also when you get old says, David.
David Eagleman: -is that the timing starts to change because there's damage to the sheathing around the nerves, and that slows down certain signals. Then the brain says, "Oh, I thought my foot should have hit the ground by now, but it hasn't, so I'm going to send out a corrective motor command." Then finally signal does come back when you've sent out this corrective motor command, and you'll stumble.
Speaker 18: With each step, you fall forward slightly, and then catch yourself from falling.
Robert: Now we're going to fall far from home. We're going to have to travel a good many light-years off the planet to fall in this particularly special and gruesome way. Our faller is Neil deGrasse Tyson, he's an astronomical physicist.
Jad: Is that what he is?
Jad: Here he is at the Herbst Theater. I like saying that, Herbst Theater in San Francisco, in front of an audience, talking about-
Robert: -falling apart.
Neil deGrasse Tyson: I'm minding my own business on the airplane and someone looks and sees what I'm doing. They find out I do astrophysics, then out come the questions, "When will life end? Will the asteroid come? Will the Aztec Calendar destroy the earth?" [laughter] It goes on and on, so I figured, people like death and mayhem. I might as well title the book with that because there's a whole chapter on how to die as you fall into a black hole, which I personally think is a kind of cool way to die. [laughter] Because what happens is, the gravity of the black hole is extreme, as you can imagine. Light doesn't even escape. Its gravity is so extreme, like traveling at the speed of light. If light doesn't come out, nothing's coming out. It's black, you fall in, you're not coming out. It's a one-way trip. You don't just die because you disappear, you die long before you disappear. As you fall in, the gravity at your feet becomes rapidly greater than the gravity at your head, so your feet start falling faster than your head does. That's a bad situation to be in. You don't really-- Initially, you kind of feel good, because it's-- We all stretch when you wake up in the morning. Initially, it feels like a stretch, but what happens is that stretch continues beyond comfort levels. You reach a point where-- And they're called the tidal forces, tides on your body basically. The tidal forces become so great that they exceed the intermolecular forces that bind your flesh. The point comes where you snap into two pieces, likely to happen at the base of your spine. Now you are two pieces. I know you didn't ask about this, but it turns out you will survive that snap because below your waist, while there are important organs, there are no vital organs below your waist. Your torso will stay alive for a little while until you bleed to death, but this all happens much faster than it would take to bleed to death. These two pieces then feel tidal forces, and then they snap into two pieces. Then they snap again into eight, and then 16, and then you're bifurcating your way down. Eventually, it's your head and multiple other parts. That will continue until you are a stream of atoms descending toward the abyss, and it turns out that's not the worst of it. [laughter] The worst-- It turns out, the fabric of space and time funnels down towards a black hole, so the space that you occupy up here is larger than a space you occupy down here. In fact, while you're getting stretched, you're getting squeezed, extruded through the fabric of space like toothpaste through a tube. [laughter] [music]
Jad: Well, we're about to--
Robert: Fall away, I think.
Jad: Oh, good. Nice one, Krulwich. Before we do though, know that we have a podcast, it's at radiolab.org. I'm Jad Abumrad.
Robert: I'm Robert Krulwich.
Joan Murray: This is Joan Murray. Radiolab is produced by Jad Abumrad and Tim Howard.
Frederick Coolidge: Their staff includes Ellen Horne, Soren Wheeler, Lulu Miller, Brenna Farrell, Pat Walters, and Lynn Levy.
Joan Murray: With help from Sharon Shattuck, [unintelligible 00:57:32] , and Nicole [inaudible 00:57:39] .
Frederick Coolidge: Special thanks to Ari Daniel Shapiro, [unintelligible 00:57:37] Emily Corwin, [unintelligible 00:57:41] , and the City Arts & Lectures in San Francisco. How's that, guys? This is Fred Coolidge, all about the hypnic jerk. Bye.
New York Public Radio transcripts are created on a rush deadline, often by contractors. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Accuracy and availability may vary. The authoritative record of New York Public Radio’s programming is the audio record.